Java Card is 15 years old

I just realized that I missed Java Card’s 15th birthday. This birthday was sometime in the end of October, 1996. I don’t have the exact date, because the only document I have is the Java Card API: Specification of the Java Virtual Machine and Application Programmer’s Interface, version 0.13, dated October 10, 1996.

Although this draft was officially authored by Sun Microsystems, Schlumberger played an important role there. This is why I am quite sure that the spec was released at the end of the month, since one of Schlumberger’s main patents on the topic was filed on October 25, 19996. The main topic of this patent is to use a high-level language to program a microcontroller, and it claims in particular the transformation of a class file into a more optimized format. Quite a good idea, at least sufficient to include this patent in the suit against Google‘s Android (which may be a proof that Android is yet another derivative of Java Card).

Good idea, but everybody trying to fit something on a card was ddoing just the same. The really brilliant idea was not to generate an optimized format, but to believe that it would be possible to start from something as different as Java. This was brilliant at the time, especially since in 1996, Java was definitely not mainstream technology, and was often considered as too expensive or too slow even on a PC. Now, that’s something for which the guys in Schlumberger can be congratulated.

Of course, they were not the only ones to try fitting unlikely things into a smart card. Researchers in Gemplus were more focused on object oriented technology, in particular Corba. And naturally, they needed to think about optimization in order to fit this into a card. They were using Forth as their base language for the Combo virtual machine. Even before that, as mentioned in this history of bytecode interpreters for smart cards, researchers at RD2P designed a bytecode interpreter, as early as 1990 (I can’t even imagine the memory sizes of cards at that time; if somebody knows, please leave a comment).

Now, the interesting part is that a patent has been filed in France (sorry, in French only). And one of the key elements of this patent was the fact that the programs are later compiled for the specific embedded virtual machine.

Not quite Java Card, though, because the patent only mentioned direct compilation from source code, not using an intermediary format (a.k.a. Java class file). The difference is slim, and I would be tempted to credit the French guys with the invention of optimized smart card code. However, there is something that the Schlumberger guys did much better: timing. The French patent, filed in 1990, was never extended into an international patent, whereas the American patent has been extended and mainained to this day.

As a final trivia note, did you smile when I mentioned that Android was a derivative of Java Card? Well, very indirectly, but somehow, a little bit. Java Card, after being initiated by Schlumberger, was maintained by Sun Microsystems. Sun’s Java Card team later convinced Sun to develop a slightly larger VM, the KVM, to address very small devices. This VM was then extended into MIDP, which became the leading platform for phones. And everybody knows that the Android team includes a number of ex-Sun employees who used to work on MIDP. So, yes, indeed, Android a a distant heir of Java Card.

2 Comments

  • Pierre P. wrote:

    The official announcement of Java Card was related to CARTES 1996 and pushed by Schlumberger.

    Happy birthday Java Card !

    And at that time RAM size chip card was from 128 to 256 bytes !

  • :D yeah, you’re right, i smiled when read part of your post about android is derivative of Java Card because i have a little bit of the same feeling.

Leave a Reply

Your email is never shared.Required fields are marked *